State Management: Built-In vs External Libraries

Every frontend developer faces the same question when their application starts growing: should I stick with the framework’s built-in state management tools or reach for an external library? The answer isn’t as straightforward as many tutorials suggest.

This article examines the trade-offs between using built-in state management features (like React’s hooks, Angular’s services, or Vue’s reactivity) versus adopting external libraries (like Redux, Zustand, or Pinia). We’ll focus on practical decision-making for small-to-medium projects that may need to scale.

Understanding State Management Fundamentals

State management is how your application tracks and updates data over time. Every framework provides basic tools for this:

• Component state: Local data that lives within a single component
• Shared state: Data accessed by multiple components
• Global state: Application-wide data like user authentication or theme preferences

Built-in tools handle these scenarios differently than external libraries, and understanding these differences is crucial for making the right choice.

Built-In State Management: Simplicity First

Modern frameworks offer robust state management capabilities out of the box. React provides hooks like useState and useContext, Angular has services and RxJS, while Vue offers its reactivity system and provide/inject pattern.

Advantages of Built-In Tools

Zero additional dependencies: Your bundle stays lean. No extra libraries means faster load times and simpler dependency management.

Framework alignment: Built-in tools are designed to work seamlessly with other framework features. They follow the same patterns and conventions your team already knows.

Minimal learning curve: New developers can contribute immediately without learning additional state management patterns.

The Prop Drilling Problem

The main limitation appears when sharing state across distant components. You end up passing props through multiple component layers—a pattern known as “prop drilling”:

// State must pass through Parent even though it doesn't use it
function Grandparent() {
  const [user, setUser] = useState(null);
  return <Parent user={user} />;
}

function Parent({ user }) {
  return <Child user={user} />;
}

function Child({ user }) {
  return <div>Hello {user?.name}</div>;
}

External Libraries: Power and Structure

State management libraries like Redux, Zustand, MobX, or Pinia provide centralized stores and established patterns for complex state logic.

When External Libraries Excel

Complex state logic: Applications with intricate data relationships benefit from centralized stores. Think document editors, dashboards, or real-time collaborative tools.

Time-travel debugging: Libraries like Redux offer powerful developer tools for tracking state changes over time—invaluable for debugging complex interactions.

Middleware and plugins: Need undo/redo functionality? Local storage persistence? Many libraries provide these features through simple middleware.

The Hidden Costs

Increased complexity: Every external library introduces new concepts. Your team must learn actions, reducers, selectors, or whatever patterns the library uses.

Boilerplate concerns: While modern tools like Redux Toolkit have reduced boilerplate significantly, you’re still writing more code than with built-in solutions.

Performance overhead: External libraries add to your bundle size. While Zustand adds only 8KB, Redux Toolkit adds about 40KB—not huge, but it accumulates.

Making the Right Choice: A Practical Framework

Here’s a decision framework based on real-world experience:

Start with Built-In Tools When:

• Building CRUD applications or content-driven sites
• Working with a small team or tight deadlines
• Your state primarily consists of form data and API responses
• Components are relatively independent

Consider External Libraries When:

• Multiple components need to modify the same complex state
• You need features like undo/redo, state persistence, or optimistic updates
• Your application has real-time collaboration features
• State logic becomes hard to test or reason about

The Middle Ground: Hybrid Approaches

You don’t need an all-or-nothing approach. Many successful applications use:

• Built-in state for component-specific UI state
• Context or provide/inject for theme and authentication
• A lightweight library like Zustand for complex features
• Server state libraries like React Query or SWR for API data

This hybrid approach keeps complexity low while solving specific pain points.

Performance Considerations

Bundle size matters, but it’s not the whole story. Consider:

Runtime performance: Built-in context can cause unnecessary re-renders in React. External libraries often optimize this better through subscriptions.

Developer performance: If your team spends hours debugging state issues, the 40KB from Redux Toolkit might be worth it.

Maintenance performance: Well-structured state management reduces bugs and makes features easier to add.

Common Pitfalls to Avoid

Over-engineering early: Don’t add Redux to a todo app. Start simple and migrate when you feel real pain.

Storing everything globally: Not all state belongs in a global store. Keep component state local when possible.

Ignoring server state: API data has different needs than UI state. Consider specialized tools for data fetching and caching.

Conclusion

The choice between built-in and external state management isn’t about which is “better”—it’s about matching the tool to your specific needs. Start with what your framework provides. When you find yourself fighting the framework’s limitations, that’s when external libraries become valuable.

For most small-to-medium projects, built-in tools combined with a good component architecture will suffice. But when complexity grows, don’t hesitate to adopt external libraries—just make sure you’re solving real problems, not imagined ones.

FAQs

Gain Debugging Superpowers

Unleash the power of session replay to reproduce bugs, track slowdowns and uncover frustrations in your app. Get complete visibility into your frontend with OpenReplay — the most advanced open-source session replay tool for developers. Check our GitHub repo and join the thousands of developers in our community.